We discuss youtube-dl, a command line program used to obtain content material from YouTube.com and different web sites. The venture’s repositories had been hosted on GitHub from the place anybody might obtain it and switch it right into a program in order that customers might obtain videos.
The RIAA has managed to shut the youtube-dl repository
However, the RIAA has compelled GitHub to close down the repository via a DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) declare for copyright infringement. When attempting to entry the repository, we now discover a message saying that it has been disabled because of a DMCA declare, thus, public entry to it has been blocked.
These sorts of claims are sometimes made towards copyrighted content material that is hosted on net pages with out permission from the copyright proprietor. Thus, GitHub particulars that this is a DMCA declare, however not a withdrawal for violating copyright. For this cause, they affirm that the repository must be withdrawn as a result of it permits to obtain music topic to copyright, and due to this fact is unlawful beneath German and American legal guidelines.
The criticism is particularly towards the youtube-dl supply code, which is designed to bypass YouTube’s safety measures and forestall unauthorized copies, together with videos of VEVO, that are solely licensed to be used on YouTube itself. In addition, within the supply code itself, they’re used as examples to obtain videos of Icona Pop, Justin Timberlake and Taylor Swift, which had been amongst people who brought on issues to obtain them.
The applications aren’t solely used to obtain music
The drawback is that youtube-dl is not solely used for downloading music, however principally for obtain any video that you’ve hosted on the platform, corresponding to listening to YouTube podcasts or a convention that you simply need to watch later offline or save to have it sooner or later. It is as in the event that they determined to ban using knives as a result of they can be utilized to kill individuals.
In addition, these kind of choices set a harmful precedent for the longer term, the place any DMCA declare could be resolved with the closure of a platform or web site just because it may be used to get unlawful content material, corresponding to different web sites or applications. That similar premise is what forces us to pay a charge when shopping for a tough drive in Spain, assuming that whoever is going to purchase it is going to take action to retailer unlawful content material. What shall be subsequent, ban video gamers like VLC as a result of they permit pirated films to play? Or even prohibit torrent obtain applications as a result of they let you obtain films.
Interestingly, the YouTube Go utility itself lets you obtain videos to your cell phone or to the SD card to have the ability to play them offline, and in that case the RIAA doesn’t appear to be bothered. Other choices, like downloading YouTube videos with Telegram, nonetheless work.